Franchise and Income Tax Formal Legal Opinions Adopted in 1989

Get Free Acrobat Reader Get Free Acrobat Reader! Most documents on this page are in the Adobe Portable Document Format (pdf). The current version of Acrobat Reader should be used to view pdf files. A free copy of the Acrobat Reader software is available from Adobe.

Appeal No. Appeal Name Date
89-SBE-001 AUTOMATIC DATA PROCESSING WEST, INC.
UNITARY BUSINESS - COMBINATION
Jan. 11, 1989
89-SBE-002 BROOKFIELD MANOR, INC., TAXPAYER, AND CHRISTIE F. SMITH, HAVILAND V. SMITH, FRANCES F. SMITH, DONNA S. POMEROY, ASSUMERS AND/OR TRANSFEREES AND HAVILAND V. AND FRANCES F. SMITH, ET AL.
LIKE-KIND EXCHANGE
Jan. 11, 1989
89-SBE-003 HUBACHER HOLDING CO.
CORPORATE LIQUIDATION
Jan. 11, 1989
89-SBE-004 ROBERT M. AND ANN T. BASS, ET AL.
INCOME FROM INTANGIBLES
NON-CALIFORNIA SOURCE INCOME
Jan. 25, 1989
89-SBE-004-A ROBERT M. AND ANN T. BASS, ET AL.
Appeal of Robert and Ann Bass, et al, 89-SBE-004, Jan. 25, 1989
Aug. 16, 1989
89-SBE-005 A.M. CASTLE & CO.
UNITARY BUSINESS – COMBINATION
Mar. 2, 1989
89-SBE-006 BELMONT REID & CO.
STATUTORY CONSTRUCTION
Mar. 2, 1989
89-SBE-007 TWENTIETH CENTURY-FOX FILM CORPORATION
BUSINESS / NONBUSINESS INCOME
DIVIDEND INCOME
UNITARY BUSINESS – DIVERSE LINES OF BUSINESS
Mar. 2, 1989
89-SBE-008 WILLAMETTE INDUSTRIES, INC.
INTERCOMPANY DIVIDENDS
Revenue and Taxation Code section 25106
Mar. 2, 1989
89-SBE-008-A WILLAMETTE INDUSTRIES, INC.
Appeal of Capitol Industries-EMI, Inc., 89-SBE-029, Oct. 31, 1989
Aug. 2, 1989
89-SBE-009 SPIRO T. AND ELINOR I. AGNEW
BURDEN OF PROOF – DEDUCTIONS
Apr. 6, 1989
89-SBE-010 JOSEPH PORRAZZO
INCOME – ESTIMATED BY FRANCHISE TAX BOARD
RETROACTIVE APPLICATION – LAW / DECISION
Apr. 6, 1989
89-SBE-011 ROBERT L. AND PHYLLIS SALABER
DEDUCTION – TRAVEL EXPENSES
Apr. 6, 1989
89-SBE-012 JAMES C. AND FERN CROCKER
TRUSTS – ABUSIVE
May 11, 1989
89-SBE-013 ESTATE OF LINDSAY C. HOWARD, WILLIAM H. HAIR, MARY W. SULLIVAN, ET AL.
DEDUCTION – TAXES PAID
ESTATES
May 11, 1989
89-SBE-014 RALPH G. AND MARTHA E. MCQUOID
ACCRUAL – NORESIDENCY
GROSS INCOME
PENSION / RETIREMENT INCOME
Appeal of Virgil and Jeanne P. Money, 83-SBE-267, Dec. 13, 1983
May 11, 1989
89-SBE-015 JAMES D. AND HELEN WITHERSPOON
PREFERENCE TAX / INCOME
May 11, 1989
89-SBE-016 ROBERT A. GOODIN AND ESTATE OF THOR F. AND MARJORIE C. WILCOX
PARTNERSHIPS
June 2, 1989
89-SBE-017 MERRILL, LYNCH, PIERCE, FENNER & SMITH, INC.
DISTORTION
SALES FACTOR
UNITARY BUSINESS – APPORTIONMENT
Revenue and Taxation Code section 25137
Appeal of Pacific Telephone, 78-SBE-028, May 4, 1978
Container Corp. v. Franchise Tax Board (1983) 463 U.S. 159
June 2, 1989
89-SBE-018 DENTAL INSURANCE CONSULTANTS, INC.
UNITARY BUSINESS – DIVERSE LINES OF BUSINESS
Aug. 2, 1989
89-SBE-019 DIANE L. MORRIS TRUST, ET AL.
PREFERENCE TAX / INCOME
Aug. 2, 1989
89-SBE-020 CHARLES A. DRACE
PREFERENCE TAX / INCOME
Aug. 2, 1989
89-SBE-021 TISHMAN REALTY & CONSTRUCTION CO., AND TISHMAN DAVIS CORPORATION, ASSUMER AND/OR TRANSFEREE
BUSINESS / NONBUSINESS INCOME
INVOLUNTARY CONVERSION
TAX BENEFIT RULE
Aug. 2, 1989
89-SBE-022 JUANITA A. DIAZ AND CONSTANCE B. WATTS
HEAD OF HOUSEHOLD
REFUND CLAIMS
Aug. 2, 1989
89-SBE-023 SAVOY HOTEL, INC.
CORPORATE LIQUIDATION
Aug. 16, 1989
89-SBE-023-A SAVOY HOTEL, INC.
Appeal of Savoy Hotel, Inc., 89-SBE-023, Aug. 16, 1989
Jan. 10, 1990
89-SBE-024 HENRY J. AND FLORENCE BRADLEY
SMALL BUSINESS STOCK
Sept. 26, 1989
89-SBE-025 RAYMOND E. AND JOY LECOMPTE
DEDUCTION – BAD DEBT
DEDUCTION – MEDICAL EXPENSES
INTEREST – ABATEMENT
INTEREST – IMPOSITION
SETTLEMENTS
Sept. 26, 1989
89-SBE-026 NORTHRIDGE FASHION CENTER, INC.
PENALTY – ESTIMATED TAX
TAX-EXEMPT ORGANIZATION
Sept. 26, 1989
89-SBE-027 JAMES B. AND LINDA PESIRI
COVENANT NOT TO COMPETE
Sept. 26, 1989
89-SBE-028 THE PROCTOR & GAMBLE MANUFACTURING COMPANY, ET AL.
PROPERTY FACTOR
UNITARY BUSINESS – APPORTIONMENT
Revenue and Taxation Code section 25129
Revenue and Taxation Code section 25137
Appeal of Union Carbide Corp., 84-SBE-057, Apr. 5, 1984
Sept. 26, 1989
89-SBE-029 CAPITOL INDUSTRIES-EMI, INC.
CONSTITUTIONALITY OF STATUTE
TREATY
UNITARY BUSINESS – COMBINATION
California Constitution, Art. III, sec. 3.5
Oct. 31, 1989
89-SBE-029-A CAPITOL INDUSTRIES-EMI, INC.
Appeal of Capitol Industries-EMI, Inc., 89-SBE-029, Oct. 31, 1989
Mar. 6, 1990
89-SBE-030 VICTOR P. ABEGG
ASSIGNMENT OF INCOME
GROSS INCOME
Nov. 29, 1989
89-SBE-031 CARMEL MORTGAGE CORPORATION
NET OPERATING LOSS
Nov. 29, 1989
89-SBE-032 CHARLES AND PENNY DREILING
DOMICILE – INDIVIDUAL
PENALTY – LATE FILING
RESIDENCY
Nov. 29, 1989